Transcoding Trends for 2015

John Riske, director of product marketing for media at Brightcove knows that operators will find an encoding bottleneck an unacceptable impediment to business growth. He says the buying criteria for operators should be around solutions that scale automatically to meet demand, without any capacity planning or other operational friction.

“Another key to avoiding operational friction and expense is to avoid encoding errors and any manual intervention in the process,” says Riske. “Content providers also need instant access to the state-of-the art for video formats and codecs so that they can deploy content as quickly as possible. Formats like HLS and DASH are evolving rapidly, and content providers are looking for solutions that get them what they need in a timely manner, without added expense or a long upgrade cycle.”

HDMI Dongles, Adaptive Bitrates Create New Challenges

A companion trend that Ericsson raises is a rise in higher versions of profiles, such as 720p50 or 720p60 full frame rate HDR. This has been driven by consumer use of HDMI dongles (such as Chromecast or Roku Streaming Stick) with 50- or 60-inch TVs as well as improving capabilities of high-end tablets.

“Use of high-resolution profiles being on consumer TV screens means that image quality is becoming more important and, particularly when it comes to valuable content such as sports, the step from 25/30 frames per second to 50/60 frames per second makes a dramatic difference to the viewing experience,” says Ericsson's Jones.

He contends that as the number of people viewing content via adaptive bitrate (ABR) formats increases, the importance to and expectations of those consumers for multiscreen services increases. “As consumers start using the ABR service as their primary source of TV viewing on larger screens than mobile devices, we’re seeing expectations grow more demanding, and greater pressure put upon TV service providers than before,” says Jones, “This trend is particularly pronounced in the U.S. where use of HDMI dongles has penetrated the most.”

With  ABR becoming a more common consumption method, particularly on big screens, greater emphasis is being placed on the video quality provided by encoding/transcoding solutions.

“Many operators are combining ABR and broadcast encoding/transcoding systems (as these are the most stable with respect to standards and configuration) and leveraging a separate ABR packaging and origin stage to manage the volatility of standards and devices on the consumption side,” observes Tom Lattie, VP, market management & development, Video Products at Harmonic.

A main preoccupation for transcode vendors at NAB 2015 will be multiscreen, as operators tug in opposite directions when it comes to hardware or software encoding and transcoding. It's a perennial theme, but two fundamental differences remain—hardware encoding has lower latency, and software encoding can more readily be tweaked for higher quality.

“For operators trying to reach any screen, a few hundred milliseconds of extra latency at the encoder is rarely an issue, while the need for quality increases as the video capabilities of our playback devices continue to improve,” contends Knowlton for Wowza.

He argues that software-based encoding is more flexible in three key ways. First, operators can continue to upgrade the encoding software as standards evolve and algorithms become more efficient, thus providing a level of future-proofing not typically available with hardware. Second, software typically provides much more granular control, allowing one to fine-tune the look or playback characteristics of the streams as needed. Third, software doesn’t tie you to a specific location, allowing you to spin up transcoder instances wherever you need them, whether on-premises or in the cloud.

Of course, there is a hybrid solution, which is to run transcoding software on computers containing video acceleration chipsets or GPUs from companies such as Intel and NVIDIA, respectively. Wowza sees significant improvements in these technologies making it possible to combine the benefits of software encoding with performance and quality similar to hardware encoders.

“With cloud infrastructure providers, such as Amazon Web Services, providing hardware-based video acceleration in some of their compute instances, it’s getting easier to get great transcoding results without buying hardware,” says Knowlton.

This article appears in the 2015 Streaming Media Sourcebook as "The State of Transcoding Solutions."

Streaming Covers
for qualified subscribers
Subscribe Now Current Issue Past Issues